Sweet Tooth

Pete Gardner

Bucky Bantershire

Marissa Jaret Winokur

Sweet Tooth

Ryder Robinson

Teddy Pinston

Lilah Collins

Polly Pinston

Lori Nasso

Mrs. Pinston

Gracie Moore

The Smile Judge

Paul Wong

The Smile Panelist (Joe)

Sarah DeVincentis

Ginger

Sasha Ivanir

Margot

Isaac Amsterdam

Warren

Jesse Gillingham

Dinah

Charlie Paluck

Bobby